The ownership structure in the Nigerian Electricity Supply Industry (NESI) is a combination of private investor ownership and state ownership under the Public Enterprises (First Schedule of Privatisation and Commercialisation) Act, Section 1(1). Generation and distribution are handled by licensed private companies through the generation companies (“GenCos”) and distribution companies (“DisCos”) respectively, although the federal government has a stake in these companies. In practice, transmission is handled by the federal government through the Transmission Company of Nigeria (TCN). However, Section 65 of the Electric Power Sector Reform Act allows the Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission to issue transmission licences.
GenCos
There are currently a total of 25 GenCos and they comprise the privatised GenCos, independent power producers (IPPs) and the generating stations under the National Integrated Power Project (NIPP), developed by the Niger Delta Power Holding Company of Nigeria. The privatised GenCos are Afam Power; Sapele Power; Egbin Power; Ughelli Power; Kainji Power Plant; Jebba Power Plant; and Shiroro Power.
The IPP plants, which are either 100% privately owned or under long-term concession, are the Shell-operated Afam VI (642MW); the Agip-operated Okpai (480MW); Ibom Power; NESCO and AES Barges (270MW); Aba Power Plant owned by Geometric Power Limited; Geregu One power plant acquired by Amperion Power and Olorunsogo One power plant acquired by Pacific Holdings; Azura Power Station; and Rivers IPP and Ugheli Power Plant managed by Transcorp.
The NIPP power stations, which have already been privatised or have privatisation plans underway, are Alaoji (1,074MW in Abia State; Benin (Ihovbor) (451MW) in Edo State; Calabar (563MW) in Cross River State; Egbema (338MW) in Imo State; Gbarain (225MW) in Bayelsa State; Geregu (434MW) in Kogi State; Olorunsogo in Ogun State; Omotosho (451MW) in Ondo State; Omoku (225MW) in Rivers State; and Sapele (Ogorode).
DisCos
The TCN manages the electricity transmission network in the country and is still fully owned by the government.
There are 11 DisCos, which are: Port-Harcourt Electricity Distribution Co; Abuja Electricity Distribution Co; Benin Electricity Distribution Co; Ibadan Electricity Distribution Co; Ikeja Electricity Distribution Co; Eko Electricity Distribution Co; Yola Electricity Distribution Co; Jos Electricity Distribution Co; Kano Electricity Distribution Co; Kaduna Electricity Distribution Co; and Enugu Electricity Distribution Co. The DisCos are mainly privately owned, with the government holding minority shares.
Principal Laws
The principal laws governing ownership and structure of the power sector include the following.
In Nigeria, there are 11 DisCos, six primary GenCos, and the TCN.
The principal investor-owned companies in the power sector are the GenCos and the DisCos, as the federal government has divested all its interests in the companies to private operators. The TCN, however, is the government-owned company that is solely responsible for the transmission of power.
Under the generation sub-sector, there are privatised GenCos, IPPs and generating stations under the NIPP. The IPP plants are either 100% privately owned or under long-term concession.
See 1.1 Principal Laws Governing the Structure and Ownership of the Power Industry.
There does not appear to be any specific regulation on foreign investment in the power industry in Nigeria. Regulation 3 of the Regulations on National Content Development for the Power Sector, 2014 encourages the participation of indigenous people in the power sector but does not prohibit foreign investment.
In this regard, foreign investment can be achieved either through foreign direct investment or foreign portfolio investment by following the requirements of Chapter 3 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 in relation to foreign companies, and Section 21 of the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission Act LFN 2004.
Restrictions/Limitations
Local content
The Regulations on National Content Development for the Power Sector, 2014 place restrictions on the importation of equipment. These regulations provide that all holders of a licence issued under the Act must ensure that first consideration is given to qualified Nigerian companies for the supply of goods and works, and for the provision of services. Also, Regulation 9(a) provides that consideration is to be given first to goods made in Nigeria and services rendered by Nigerian firms in the awarding of contracts.
Where, however, such goods or equipment are not available in Nigeria, they may be imported with payment of the necessary import duties.
For the award of contracts and to secure employment in the sector, priority should be given to Nigerians. However, there is the provision of a waiver where necessary.
Importation and repatriation of capital
Another area of restriction is in respect of capital importation and capital repatriation. Capital must be imported using an authorised agent licensed by the Central Bank of Nigeria. Also, due process must be followed in taking capital out of Nigeria.
Property rights
Nigerian law protects the rights of citizens and indeed juristic persons such as companies to acquire and own property (assets) anywhere in Nigeria. Such properties cannot be confiscated unless in compliance with the orders of a court of law, after legal process has been followed. Properties may also be compulsorily acquired by the state in the public interest, provided that adequate compensation is made to the owner of such property.
Section 25 of the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission (NIPC) Act guarantees that foreigners can freely invest in Nigeria and such investments are preserved from expropriation or compulsory acquisition by any government of the federation, except when such acquisition is in the national interest or for a public purpose and under a law which makes provision for (a) payment of fair and adequate compensation, and (b) a right of access to the courts for the determination of the investor’s interest or right and the amount of compensation to which the investor is entitled.
Access to domestic courts is a constitutionally guaranteed right under Section 6(6b) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended), where it is stated that the judicial powers of the court will extend to all matters between persons, or between the government or authorities and any persons in Nigeria, and to all actions and proceedings relating thereto, for the determination of any question regarding the civil rights and obligations of that person. This provision vests in any person the right to approach the court for the resolution of any dispute.
Submission of disputes to international arbitration and applicability of international law is not prohibited, provided that the same is agreed by parties in their contracts.
Incentives
Several incentives are provided in various Nigerian tax laws that are also applicable to investments in the power sector, such as, under the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission Act, Cap N117 LFN 2004 and pioneer status under the Industrial Development (Income Tax Relief) Act, Cap I7 LFN 2004. A pioneer certification exempts qualifying companies from payment of income taxes for a period not exceeding five years. It also grants accelerated capital allowances after the expiration of the tax holiday and tax-exempt dividends, among others.
In 2015, NERC issued the Regulations on Feed-in Tariff for Renewable Energy-Sourced Electricity in Nigeria 2015. These regulations are aimed at stimulating investment in the renewable energy/alternative energy sector of the country with a target of 2,000MW from renewable sources such as biomass, small hydro, wind and solar by 2020. Unfortunately, this target is yet to be reached, as it was recently reported in June 2022 that the federal government and some state governments are still working to produce 2,000 MW of off-grid electricity through solar energy. Some of the objectives of the regulations include establishing a guaranteed price for electricity generated from renewables for a fixed period that guarantees an adequate return on investment, as well as establishing an obligation to purchase power generated from qualifying renewable energy sources. In effect, the regulations, in Chapter 2 Regulation 5f, place an obligation on the DisCos to source a minimum of 50% of their total procurement from renewable, while the remaining 50% is to be sourced from Nigerian Bulk Electricity Trading (NBET) Plc.
There are no sector-specific laws dealing with the sale or transfer of power assets. Any such sale or transfer is subject to regular Nigerian laws governing such transactions, such as the Companies and Allied Matters Act, the Investment and Securities Act, the Infrastructure Concession Regulatory Commission Act, etc. Furthermore, Section 69 of the Electric Power Sector Reform Act prohibits the transfer or assignment of power assets and licences without the consent of NERC.
The NERC Order on the procedure for obtaining the approval of the commission for the assignment/ceding of a licence, transfer of undertaking or change in shareholding of licensed entities was issued in September 2013 pursuant to Section 69 of the Electric Power Sector Reform Act (EPSRA) and regulates the transfer of assets or interest in assets in the NESI.
The principal laws that govern the sale of generation, transmission and distribution assets, and the amalgamation or merger of power industry entities are as follows:
Regulators
NERC
Section 69 (1) of the EPSRA provides that a licensee may not assign or cede their licence or transfer their undertaking or any part thereof, by way of sale, mortgage, lease, exchange or otherwise, without the prior consent of NERC.
The NERC Order on the Procedure for Obtaining the Approval of the Commission for the Assignment/Ceding of a Licence, Transfer of Undertaking or Change in Shareholding of Licensed Entities therefore sets out the procedure for the transfer of a licence, an assignment/ceding of undertakings of a licensee, or any change in shareholding of a licensee.
For any of the applications, an applicant is to submit an application to NERC for approval, supported by the following accompanying documents stipulated in Appendix 1 of the NERC Order.
The licensee must also submit an application for a licence form duly completed by the new owner, ensure that all outstanding debt owed to NERC is settled, and pay all relevant fees in connection with the application. NERC will thereafter conduct legal due diligence on the transferee/assignee/new shareholder. Where this is successful, NERC will grant its approval of the transaction. The timeline for the completion of the application is between three and six months. NERC typically requires that the purchaser of assets or an acquirer of a licensee must have sufficient technical and financial capability to participate in the NESI. There are no stated thresholds used in determining whether a purchaser or an acquirer is technically or financially capable to participate in the NESI. NERC’s decision in this regard is subject to its discretion.
SEC
Any merger, acquisition, or external restructuring transaction between or among companies, involving assets or turnover above NGN500 million requires the prior review and approval of the SEC (the apex regulatory body in Nigeria for the regulation of capital markets, mergers, acquisitions and other forms of business combinations).
The procedure for application is:
The process typically takes between three and six months.
The central authority with the responsibility of overseeing the NESI is NERC. Its main role is to issue licences and to regulate persons engaged in the generation, transmission, system operation, distribution and trading of electricity in Nigeria, as well as to preserve efficient industry and market structures in the electricity sector.
With respect to transmission, the TCN is solely responsible for purchasing generated power from the GenCos and selling this to the DisCos. Transmission grids and facilities are fully operated and maintained by the TCN.
It is within the scope of NERC’s functions, as contained in Section 32 of the EPSRA, to ensure that there is electricity supply adequacy, generation planning and development.
Pursuant to Section 96 of the EPSRA, NERC made a Meter Asset Provider and National Mass Metering Regulations which commenced on 9 August 2021. The objective of the regulations is to provide guidelines for the provision of meters to customers of successor electricity distribution licensees.
Some time in April 2021, NERC issued a tool named the "NERC distribution usage fee tool". The essence of the tool is to form a basis for negotiation on suitable usage fees between distribution companies and mini-grid operators in Nigeria, when a mini-grid operator is utilising the assets of a distribution company at the location of a mini-grid.
Pursuant to Section 76 of the EPSR Act 2005, NERC has the power to establish a methodology for determining electricity tariffs in the NESI and subsequently issue a tariff order called the Multi-Year Tariff Order (MYTO) that sets out tariffs for the generation, transmission and distribution of electricity in Nigeria. In April 2021, NERC issued a Mini Grid MYTO Model 2021. The MYTO is a tariff model for incentive-based regulation that seeks to reward performance above certain benchmarks, reduce technical and non-technical/commercial losses and lead to cost recovery and improved performance standards from all industry operators in the NESI. The purpose of the MYTO is to set cost-reflective tariffs which will allow the power sector to be properly funded and functional. It provides a 15-year tariff path for the NESI with limited minor reviews each year in the light of changes in a limited number of parameters (such as inflation, interest rates, exchange rates and generation capacity) and major reviews every five years, when all of the inputs are reviewed with stakeholders.
The Electric Power Sector Reform Act 2005 continues to be the primary legislation, however, regulating electricity power generation, transmission and distribution in Nigeria.
There does not presently appear to be any other new policy that will result in material changes to the power industry except for the Electric Power Sector Reform Act (Amendment) Bill 2019 which is still pending before the National Assembly.
One unique aspect of the NESI is the sole-transmitter model, where the TCN is solely responsible for transmission of all generated power to the DisCos. Another unique aspect is the single-buyer model, where NBET buys up all generated power and sells it to the DisCos. This model ensures regular supply and demand of power in the NESI.
The structure of the NESI wholesale market is progressively competitive, currently based on the single-buyer model co-ordinated by NBET. NBET buys up the power generated by the GenCos and sells this to the DisCos, who sell to the final consumers.
EPSRA Regulations
Section 68 of the EPSRA regulations provides for the granting of trading licences for purchasing, selling and trading electricity. The EPSRA also provides for the granting of temporary licensing for bulk purchasers who have the right to purchase power and other related services from GenCos and IPPs, and to resell these to DisCos and other eligible customers.
Role of the Power Purchase Agreements
The wholesale electricity market has been designed around NBET as the bulk purchaser. NBET has entered into several power purchase agreements (PPAs) with GenCos and IPPs for generated energy. NBET has also entered into energy-only PPAs. Although this latter type of PPA includes a capacity component, the payments made are equivalent to the energy generated. The result is that the NESI consists of two types of PPAs. The price of wholesale electricity is largely determined by the PPAs on a GenCo-by-GenCo basis. Although NERC issues tariffs to the GenCos, these form the baseline for the GenCos’ tariffs and do not indicate the actual cost of wholesale electricity. These rates are reviewed periodically, taking into consideration the prevailing exchange rate, the rate of inflation and the current price of gas. Consequently, the price of power generated varies from GenCo to GenCo.
Sale of Electricity
The NBET, after purchasing power from the GenCos and IPPs, sells this to the DisCos in line with the MYTO for the respective DisCos, which sets out the tariff applicable to each DisCo.
Nigeria exports power to some African countries such as Niger, Togo and the Benin Republic under bilateral trade agreements. Presently, Nigeria does not import power from any country. Nigeria is also a member of the West African Power Pool (WAPP), an agency of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), under which arrangement it trades electricity with some ECOWAS countries.
The GenCos operate either hydro-electric or thermal gas-fired power plants. The installed capacity of hydro-electric power in Nigeria is 1,938.4 MW with an available capacity of 1,060 MW, while thermal gas-fired plants have a total installed capacity of 8,457.6 MW with an available capacity of 4,996 MW. In the area of renewable energy, NERC issued the Regulations on Feed-in Tariffs for Renewable Energy Sourced Electricity in Nigeria 2015. These regulations are aimed at stimulating investment in the renewable energy sector of the country with a target of 2,000 MW from renewable sources, such as biomass, small hydro, wind and solar, by 2020. Some of the objectives of the regulations include establishing a guaranteed price for electricity generated from renewables for a fixed period of time that guarantees adequate return on investment, as well as establishing an obligation to purchase power generated from qualifying renewable energy sources. In effect, the regulations placed an obligation on the DisCos to source a minimum of 50% of their total procurement from renewable, while the remaining 50% was to be sourced from NBET. It is, however, regrettable that at present the 2020 target is yet to be met.
There are no specific laws governing market concentration limits in the NESI. Under the EPSRA, NERC can enforce competition in the electricity sector at different stages of the NESI. NERC is also responsible for ensuring that the abuse of market power is prevented or mitigated, and it may conduct investigations, undertake inquiries or monitor licensees for this purpose. NERC can also impose penalties and fines, and make any other orders consistent with discharging its role as a regulator of the power industry in Nigeria.
The EPSRA generally regulates all activities in the NESI, while NERC is the primary regulator and is charged with the responsibility of ensuring a competitive NESI. In addition, the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC), pursuant to the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission Act 2018, is the primary agency of government for ensuring and enforcing a competitive market in all sectors of the economy as well as monitoring and curtailing anti-competitive practices by big players. The FCCPC is empowered to conduct investigations; issue summons to appear and produce documents to companies under investigation; enter into, search and seize valuable documents and materials, including electronic devices; and sanction any anti-competitive or monopolistic activity by companies, among other functions. The FCCPC also has prosecutorial powers and may prosecute defaulting companies accordingly. Punishment for breaches of the provisions of the FCCPC Act range from fines to imprisonment or both.
In Nigeria the major law governing climate change is the Climate Change Act, 2021. This Act provides a framework for mainstreaming climate change actions, provides for a system of carbon budgeting and provides for the establishment of the National Council on Climate Change. Other relevant legislations/policies include:
In relation to the power industry, the Climate Change Act provides that a National Climate Change Action Plan be formulated by the Secretariat (the Administrative Arm of the National Council on Climate Change) in consultation with the federal ministries responsible for environment, budget and national planning, every five-year cycle. The said Action Plan will prescribe the measures and mechanisms to enhance energy conservation, efficiency, and the use of renewable energy in the industrial, commercial, transport, domestic and other sectors.
On how laws/policies are directed to limit carbon emission, the Climate Change Act provides that the National Council on Climate Change (the "Council”) is to collaborate with the federal ministries responsible for environment and trade, to develop and implement a mechanism for carbon emission trading. The Council is also to collaborate with the Federal Inland Revenue Service to develop a mechanism for carbon tax in Nigeria.
The proceeds of emission trading and tax are to be paid into the Climate Change Fund established under the Act. The fund is to be applied to incentivising private and public entities in their efforts towards transiting to clean energy and sustaining a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, among other purposes.
Concerning emission limits and the mechanism used to limit carbon emissions:
At COP26 in Glasgow, Nigerian President Muhammadu Buhari announced that Nigeria will cut its carbon emissions and reach net-zero by 2060. The president subsequently signed into law a new Climate Act, with a view to achieving net-zero greenhouse gas emissions between 2050 and 2070. The said Act also provides that the Federal Ministry of Environment will, in consultation with the Federal Ministry for National Planning, set a carbon budget for Nigeria, to keep average increases in global temperature within 2°C and pursue efforts to limit the temperature increase to l.5°C above pre-industrial levels. The carbon budget is to be revised periodically in line with Nigeria's nationally determined contributions and with a view to complying with Nigeria's international obligations.
The Nigerian government, through the Department of Climate Change in the Federal Ministry of Environment, developed a 2050 Long Term Vision for Nigeria (LTV2050) towards the development of Nigeria’s long strategy named the Long-Term Low Emissions Development Strategy (LT-LEDS). The vision is that:
“by 2050, Nigeria is a country [with a] low-carbon, climate-resilient, high-growth circular economy that reduces its current level of emissions by 50%, moving towards having net-zero emissions across all sectors of its development in a gender-responsive manner.”
The retirement of carbon-based generation in Nigeria is gradual and its major drivers are the Climate Change Act and the Nigeria Energy Transition Master Plan (ETP). The Climate Change Act in a bid to achieve its year 2060 net-zero plan has put in place certain structures to encourage the use of clean energy. Some of these initiatives include the design of a National Action Plan, the creation of a carbon budget, and the introduction of a carbon tax and carbon emissions trading system.
The ETP has adopted a phase-down approach, as opposed to a phase-out approach, in its transition plans. For the oil and gas sector, the plan seeks to reduce emissions as part of the global response to climate change mitigation using technologies such as carbon capture and storage (CCS), direct air capture, hydrogen fuel, etc.
With respect to the power sector, emissions will be reduced via the use of solar energy, as renewables replace natural gas as a transition fuel.
Furthermore, Section 64 (h) of the Petroleum Industry Act (2021) gives the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation Ltd (NNPC) the responsibility to engage in the business of renewables and other energy investments.
There are however no specific timelines for early retirement of carbon-based energy in Nigeria. The same applies to compensations.
Attention to developing renewable sources has become stronger and it is gradually becoming the focal point of Nigeria’s electricity policy. Laws, policies and other regulatory instruments geared towards stimulating investment in renewables have been introduced to achieve this goal.
The EPSRA, which primarily regulates Nigeria’s electricity sector, established NERC as the apex regulator of the sector and the REA was charged with the responsibility of expanding the main grid; developing isolated mini-grid systems; and promoting renewable energy power generation.
The Electricity Bill 2021 (the “Bill”) is currently pending before the National Assembly. The Bill aims, among other things, to create an enabling environment to attract investment in renewable energy sources, to improve the use of renewable energy off-grid and mini-grid solutions for electrification, and to promote indigenous capacity in technology for renewable energy sources.
Regulations
NERC has issued several regulations to promote the development of alternative energy sources in Nigeria.
Other policies include the National Biofuel Policy and Incentives; the Renewable Energy Master Plan, 2005 and 2012; and the National Renewable Energy Action Plan for 2015–30 as adopted by the National Council on Power on 14 July 2016.
Capacity Target
Nigeria’s Renewable Energy Master Plan seeks to increase the supply of renewable electricity from 13% of total electricity generation in 2015 to 23% in 2025 and 36% by 2030. Renewable electricity would then account for 10% of Nigeria's total energy consumption by 2025.
Fiscal Incentives
There is currently no specific competitive procurement process for alternative energy-sourced power generation.
There are numerous incentives provided in various Nigerian tax laws that are also applicable to investments in renewable energy, such as under the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission Act, Cap N117 LFN 2004 and the pioneer status under the Industrial Development (Income Tax Relief) Act, Cap I7 LFN 2004. A pioneer certification exempts qualifying companies from payment of income taxes for a period not exceeding five years. It also grants accelerated capital allowances after the expiration of the tax holiday, and tax-exempt dividends, among others.
NERC has stated that the following incentives, among others, will be available to investments in renewable energy:
The principal law that governs the construction and operation of generation facilities in Nigeria is the EPSRA. The Act governs the NESI and the NESI value chain (including electricity generation, transmission, distribution, supply and trading). The Act also established NERC, which was saddled with the responsibility of licensing and regulating persons engaged in the generation, transmission, system operation, distribution and trading of electricity.
Other policies that regulate the construction and operation of generation facilities include:
The EPSRA provides that no person shall construct, own or operate an undertaking or in any way engage in the business of electricity generation, excluding captive generation, without a licence.
A person may, however, construct, own or operate an undertaking for generating electricity not exceeding 1 MW in aggregate at a site or in an undertaking for the distribution of electricity with a capacity not exceeding 100 kW in aggregate as a site or such other capacity as NERC may determine from time to time.
Approval to Construct a Generation Facility
Site approval
Before siting and commencement of construction of a power plant, the licensee is mandated to first obtain approval of the site by NERC and other relevant agencies as well as the consent of the host community.
Every application for generation site approval by a licensee is to be accompanied by a topographic map in 1–10,000 of the project site, a geotechnical investigations report, site layout plan and EIA report. The licensee must submit the following:
Plant design approval
A licensee is expected to submit a detailed engineering design of the power station to NERC based on applicable national and international engineering codes. The design will ensure that when the power plant is built it will be able to generate its design capacity in a cost-effective, reliable and safe manner with minimal impact on the environment.
Permit to construct power plants
Licensees are expected to comply with all sections of the Nigerian building codes and environmental health and safety regulations requirements, and obtain a construction permit from NERC for the commencement of construction of the plant.
Approval to Operate a Generation Facility
Before any person can operate generation facilities in Nigeria, such person must first obtain a generation licence. The NERC Application for Licences Regulations, 2010 provide the documentation and procedure for license applications as follows.
Pre-application stage
The licensee is expected to have carried out pre-application requirements such as registration of a company in Nigeria, possession of a tax clearance certificate evidencing payment of three years of tax immediately before the application, etc.
Application stage
An application for a licence must be made in writing on a specified form and addressed to the chairman of NERC. It must be accompanied by the documents necessary for a generation licence. The applicant must pay a non-refundable fee, as fixed by NERC, for processing the application.
Evaluation stage
The application will be evaluated by three divisions of NERC – the legal licensing and enforcement division, the engineering standards and safety division and the market competition and rates division. The applicant must arrange an EIA of the site as well as an evaluation of how effluents and discharges will be handled. The applicant must have entered an off-take agreement or, where the applicant proposes to supply power to the grid, a PPA will have to be entered with NBET.
Notification and publication of notice stage
NERC will notify the applicant of the completeness of the application within 30 days of passing a resolution to that effect. The applicant will publish a statutory public notice to that effect in at least two daily newspapers, and the notice will state the period within which any objection or representation in connection with the application must be made to the Commission.
Objection and hearing stage
Any person that has an objection to the granting of the licence is expected to file a written objection within 21 days from the date of the public notice. Objections, if any, will be heard by NERC before the granting or refusal of the licence.
Approval or refusal of licence
After due consideration of the application and the inquiry, if any, the Commission will either grant or refuse to grant the licence.
The requisite terms and conditions that must be fulfilled before approval to construct and operate a generation facility are granted are as follows.
Approvals for Construction of Generation Facilities
A licensee constructing a generation plant is required to comply with the conditions in the Nigerian Electricity Supply and Installation Standards Regulations ("NESIS Regulations") 2015, which include:
The terms and conditions of approval to construct a generation facility can only be relaxed (derogated) on the approval of NERC. The NESIS Regulations provide that where a licensee is unable to comply with any of the provisions of the Regulations, such licensee shall comply with the processes for seeking derogation stipulated in the Guidelines on Derogation from Technical Codes and Standards in Electricity Generation, Transmission, Distribution and Supply in Nigeria.
Terms and Conditions for Operation of a Licence
The EPSRA, particularly Section 71, provides that a licence may be subject to certain terms and conditions as may be prescribed or determined by NERC.
The EPSRA also provides that the terms and conditions of a licence may require the licensee to:
The licence must contain terms and conditions for the licence to cease to have effect or be modified by the Commission.
A licensee does not have eminent domain or expropriation rights to obtain surface access and use of land in Nigeria. The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria guarantees a person’s right to own property and also restricts compulsory acquisition of a person’s interest in the property except in exceptional circumstances where the acquisition is for public use.
All land in each state of Nigeria is vested in the governor of that state, and such land is held in trust and administered for the use and common benefit of all Nigerians in accordance with the provisions of the Land Use Act. The governor of each state has the power to grant right of occupancy to individuals seeking interest in the land.
NERC (Acquisition of Land and Access Rights for Electricity Projects) Regulations, 2012 make provision for voluntary and compulsory acquisition of land for electricity projects. NERC encourages voluntary acquisition of land for such projects.
A licensee is expected, prior to embarking on any electricity project on any land not owned by it, to notify the owner of its intention to use the land for the said project and obtain the free fair informed consent of the owner.
However, compulsory acquisition will be adopted where:
Where the occupier or landowner fails to give consent within a reasonable period, the licensee may apply to NERC for a declaration that the land is required for the purposes of generation, transmission or distribution of electricity. Upon a declaration by NERC that said land is required by a licensee after the landowner has had the opportunity to make representations against such a declaration, the compulsory acquisition of the land will be carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Land Use Act. By virtue of the Land Use Act, the governor will revoke the right of occupancy upon issue of a notice in the Gazette by or on behalf of the president that such land is required by the government for public purposes. The licensee will thereafter process the acquisition of access rights as stipulated by the Office of the Surveyor-General of the Federation.
Note that a licensee is expected to compensate landowners or persons affected by the compulsory acquisition of land.
Besides paragraph 1.5.1 of the Nigerian Electricity Supply and Installation Standards Regulations, 2015 which provides that any licensee that is decommissioning a generation facility is required to comply with the EPSRA, the NESIS and all regulations, codes and standards made pursuant to the EPSRA, there are no specific sector regulations or policies on decommissioning of generation facilities in Nigeria.
Note that the Federal Ministry of Environment developed a guideline to assist facility owners on the appropriate process to follow for successful decommissioning of a facility and rehabilitation of the surrounding environment.
The purpose of this guideline is to provide clear directions and guidance on the step-by-step process involved in decommissioning a facility in Nigeria. The guideline is applicable to decommissioning generation facilities in Nigeria, since there is a specific provision applicable to the power sector in Nigeria. A licensee is required to comply with these guidelines and any others prescribed by a relevant body from time to time.
The guidelines provide the following basic requirements for decommissioning:
The NESI and value chain, including the construction and operation of transmission facilities, are primarily regulated by the EPSRA.
Section 65 of the EPSRA empowers NERC to grant a transmission licence authorising the licensee to carry on grid construction, operation and maintenance of a transmission system within Nigeria, or that connects Nigeria with a neighbouring jurisdiction.
The TCN is the only company that is licensed to carry on grid construction, operation and maintenance of the transmission system in Nigeria. The TCN's transmission licence is obtained under NERC (Application for Licences: Generation Transmission, Systems Operations, Distribution and Trading) Regulations 2006 (now 2010).
The NESIS Regulations control the construction of transmission facilities in Nigeria. The regulations outline the standard technical requirements for the construction of civil works and buildings for the 330/132/33 kV transmission and sub-transmission, sub-stations of the national grid of Nigeria, and the construction of civil works including layouts, structures, buildings and foundations, electro-mechanical works, and bus-bar arrangements, among other things.
Concerning the operation of transmission facilities, Section 66 of the EPSRA empowers NERC to grant a system operating licence empowering the carrier of such licence to construct transmission scheduling, transmission congestion management, international transmission in management, procurement and system planning, etc. The operation of transmission facilities is further regulated by the NERC Grid Code. The grid code regulates the operation, procedures and principles for the transmission system, and is geared towards achieving an effective, well co-ordinated and economic transmission system for the NESI.
To obtain approval for a transmission licence in Nigeria, an application is required to be made in writing and submitted to the chairman of NERC, including the following:
For the operation of transmission lines, the applicant must apply in writing for a transmission system operator licence. The application must include the following:
Before a transmission licence is granted, an EIA is required to be conducted and a report submitted. Upon submission of the application, if NERC finds the application to be complete, filing of the application will be acknowledged, and the applicant will be required to publish a statutory public notice of the application in two daily newspapers. The purpose of this is to invite objections from the public. Where there is an objection, which is neither frivolous nor vexatious, NERC may proceed to place the application for hearing, upon its evaluation and consideration of any objection filed. The findings of the Commission following the inquiry/hearing will be recorded in writing. NERC may thereafter grant or reject the application, based on certain considerations.
The EPSRA empowers NERC to set the terms and conditions for the granting of licences in the NESI. The EPSRA does, however, give direction as to what may be expected of a licensee. The terms and conditions of a licence may require a licensee to:
The EPSRA also provides that every licence will be deemed to contain a provision that a licensee complies with the market rules to the extent applicable to the licensee.
Furthermore, the NESIS Regulations provide certain terms and conditions on issues such as the qualifications of engineering personnel, inspection of electrical facilities, documentation and reporting obligations, EIA reports, and the design of civil works and specification of materials must consider the environmental impact of all elements, etc.
Importantly, the grid code provides that the development of the transmission network must be planned in advance, with adequate time to obtain all the necessary approvals, such as EIAs, forest clearance, road or railway clearance, clearance from aviation authorities, and rights of way. A proposed development plan must also allow for detailed engineering and construction work to be carried out.
Nigerian Law does not grant a proponent eminent domain, condemnation or expropriation rights for surface access and use. The Land Use Act 1978, however, gives the government the power to compulsorily acquire land on the grounds of public purpose. Further to this, the EPSRA allows a licensee who requires a parcel of land, in which another person has a legal interest, for the purposes of fulfilling their obligations under the licence, to apply to NERC for a declaration that the land is required for public purposes. Based on the application and any further information requested by the Commission, the Commission may invite and consider submissions from the Commissioner for Lands of the State where the land is situated.
As a result of the inquiry and subject to the satisfaction of NERC, and certain exceptions and conditions as may be determined by NERC, the Commission may declare that the land identified by the licensee is required for the purpose of transmission of electricity. This declaration will only be made after the owner of the land has been given an opportunity to make representations against such a declaration.
Following such declaration, the president will confirm the position by issuing a notice in the Gazette to the effect that the land is required for public purpose. The governor of the state where the land is situated, further to the provisions of Section 28 (4) of the Land Use Act, will thereafter revoke the existing right of occupancy and vest that right on the licensee to the exclusion of any previous holder.
It is worthy of note that the previous title-holder may claim compensation under the Land Use Act. Section 77(9) of the EPSRA provides that the previous holder of the title will be entitled to claim compensation in line with the provisions of the Land Use Act. The Nigerian courts have held that where land has been compulsorily acquired, the person whose land has been so compulsorily acquired is entitled to reasonable compensation.
The TCN has an exclusive licence to provide transmission services in Nigeria. The implication of this is that its licence covers transmission across the whole nation. This extends to the exclusive right to construct and operate transmission facilities across Nigeria. In essence, there are no competitors.
The exclusive right bestowed on the TCN came into being upon the signing into law of the EPSRA, which led to the formation of the Power Holding Company of Nigeria (PHCN) with a transitory framework in March 2005. The NEPA was unbundled by the EPSRA into 18 companies: six GenCos, one transmission company, and 11 DisCos. All were issued operations licences.
The EPSRA is the principal law regulating the NESI in Nigeria. Other than that, transmission services and charges are regulated by NERC and the Commission has stipulated the means in its NERC Multi-year Tariff Order 2015, for the Transmission Company of Nigeria. This Order spans from 1 January 2016 to 31 December 2024.
By the Tariff Order, NERC established the regulated Transmission Use of System (TUOS) charge to be paid to the TCN by the DisCos.
The Market Rules as designed by the market operator also provide for the regulation of the terms of service in the NESI. Among other things, the Market Rules set out the responsibilities of participants in the TCN, the TSP, the system operator and the market operator in relation to trading, co-ordination, dispatch and contract nomination, pricing of imbalances and ancillary services, metering, settlement and payments. The Market Rules also provide a framework for the resolution of disputes among participants or between participants on the one hand and the system operator or market operator on the other, on matters relating to the Market Rules and the Grid Code.
The Market Rules are a regulatory instrument designed to establish and govern an efficient, competitive, transparent and reliable market for the sale and purchase of wholesale electricity and ancillary services in Nigeria and to ensure that the Grid Code and the Market Rules work together to secure efficient co-ordination and adequate participation in the Nigerian electricity market.
It is noteworthy that the GenCos and DisCos may enter into agreements with the TCN, eg, a grid connection agreement. These agreements will often include terms of service mutually agreed upon by the parties.
NERC, in its MYTO-2015 model, approved the Transmission Use of System (TOUS) charges based on the TCN’s submission and the structure of the MYTO-2015 model. These charges are subject to a bi-annual review. During these reviews, NERC may vary the TCN’s tariff if there is a material change in the inflation rate, exchange rate, and generation capacity used in the derivation of the TCN’s tariffs.
Pursuant to Section 50 of the EPSRA, any person aggrieved by the decision of NERC with respect to tariffs and prices can apply to NERC for a review of that decision. Moreover, NERC may call for objections or representations in connection with proposed tariffs prior to adoption.
The TCN is responsible for the national inter-connected transmission system of substations and power lines and the provision of open-access transmission services. The open-access service is available to all holders of generation or distribution licences. The open-access system is regulated by the Grid Code for the Nigeria Electricity Transmission System (the "Grid Code").
The Grid Code is designed to facilitate efficient production and supply of electricity for all users of the transmission system and the TCN itself, in a non-discriminatory manner.
The Grid Code stipulates that any user that proposes a connection to the transmission system, either through a new substation, modification of an existing substation, or in an existing substation, must send an application to the Transmission Service Provider (TSP).
The application form must include the following information, among other things:
The form is to be accompanied by certain documents and requirements.
Note that the TSP is not mandated to accept every application made to it by users for connection to the transmission line. After evaluating the application, the TSP is required to inform the user of the success or failure of their application. In the event that an application is rejected:
On the other hand, where the application is successful, the TSP must submit to the user an offer to connect to the transmission system. This offer must include the following:
The construction and operation of electricity distribution facilities in the NESI is governed by the EPSRA. Any company intending to construct a distribution network must first obtain the approval of NERC. Section 67 of the EPSRA makes provisions for the acquisition of distribution licences.
Furthermore, NERC has issued the NERC (Independent Electricity Distribution) Regulations, 2012, (the "IEDN Regulations") aimed at providing the standard rules for the issuance of distribution licences to qualified operators and licensees to engage in electricity distribution, independent of the distribution system operated by the distribution company of Nigeria.
The IEDN Regulations facilitate the operation of independent power distribution networks by individuals or groups and allow communities, local and state governments to invest in electricity distribution networks in areas without access to the grid or distribution network, as well as areas that are poorly serviced.
With respect to the construction of distribution networks and facilities, the NESIS Regulations apply. There is also the Distribution Code for the Nigeria Electricity Distribution System containing the day-to-day operating procedures and principles governing the development, operation and maintenance of effective, well co-ordinated and functional distribution networks for the electricity sector in Nigeria.
To obtain approval for a distribution licence in Nigeria, an application is required to be made in writing and submitted to the chairman of NERC including the following:
The construction and maintenance of distribution networks is regulated by the Distribution Code for the Nigeria Electricity Distribution System and the NESIS Regulations.
Upon submission of the application, and if upon review, NERC finds the application to be complete, the filing of the application will be acknowledged, and the applicant will be required to publish a statutory public notice of the application in two daily newspapers. The purpose of this is to invite objections from the public. Where there is an objection, which is neither frivolous nor vexatious, NERC will make the petition available to the applicant for a reply. Consequently, NERC may proceed to place the application for hearing, upon its evaluation and consideration of any objection filed. The findings of the Commission following the inquiry/hearing will be recorded in writing. NERC may thereafter grant or reject the application based on certain considerations.
If NERC intends to refuse to grant the licence, it must notify the applicant and the applicant is permitted to make adequate representations to the Commission within 21 days of receipt of such notification from the Commission. The Commission will consider the representation made by the applicant and, if the representation is unsuccessful, or no representation is made, will duly notify the applicant in writing that the application for a licence has been refused. The reasons for refusing to grant a licence will be clearly communicated in writing to the applicant.
Conversely, where the representation is successful, the licence will be approved.
The EPSRA empowers NERC to set the terms and conditions for the granting of licences in the NESI. The EPSRA does, however, give direction as to what may be expected of a licensee. The terms and conditions of a licence may require the licensee to:
The EPSRA also provides that every licence will be deemed to contain a provision that a licensee complies with the market rules to the extent applicable to the licensee.
Further, the NESIS Regulations provide for certain terms and conditions on issues such as the qualifications of engineering personnel, inspection of electrical facilities, documentation and reporting obligations, and EIA reports, and the design of civil works and specification of materials must consider the environmental impact of all elements, etc.
With respect to the amendment of the terms and conditions of licences, the NERC (Application for Licences: Generation Transmission, Systems Operations, Distribution and Trading) Regulations 2010 in Section 13(a) stipulate that NERC may amend the terms and conditions of a licence, upon application by the licensee or upon NERC receiving a complaint from any consumer, eligible customer or association of eligible customers, or other licensee.
For all amendments not initiated by the licensee, the Commission may amend the terms and conditions if satisfied that:
The procedure for application for a licence also applies to the application for amendment of the terms and conditions of a licence. For instance, as stipulated in Section 10 of the Regulation, the applicant would be required to publish the notice of proposed amendments in the manner specified by NERC to invite objections.
Nigerian law does not grant a proponent eminent domain, condemnation or expropriation rights for surface access and use. The Land Use Act does, however, give the government the power to compulsorily acquire land on the grounds of public purpose. Further to this, the EPSRA allows a licensee who requires a parcel of land in which another person has a legal interest, for the purposes of fulfilling their obligations under the licence, to apply to NERC for a declaration that the land is required for public purpose. Based on the application and any further information requested by the Commission, the Commission may invite and consider submissions from the Commissioner for Lands of the state where the land is situated.
Upon the inquiry and subject to the satisfaction of NERC and certain exceptions and conditions as may be determined by NERC, the Commission may declare that the land identified by the licensee is required for the purpose of the transmission of electricity. This declaration will only be made after the owner of the land has been given the opportunity to make representations against such declaration.
Following such declaration, the president shall confirm the position by issuing a notice in the Gazette to the effect that the land is required for public purpose. The governor of the state where the land is situated, further to the provisions of Section 28 (4) of the Land Use Act, will thereafter revoke the existing right of occupancy and vest that right in the licensee to the exclusion of any previous holder.
It is worthy of note that the previous title-holder may claim compensation under the Land Use Act. Section 77(9) of the EPSRA provides that the previous holder of title is entitled to claim compensation in line with the provisions of the Land Use Act. The Nigerian courts have held that where land has been compulsorily acquired, the person whose land has been so compulsorily acquired is entitled to reasonable compensation.
Electricity distribution entities have geographical exclusivity rights conferred on them by their franchise. However, there are exceptions to this. Under Article 6 (1) of the NERC Mini-Grid Regulation, 2016 mini-grid developers may apply for permits for this purpose.
Geographical Delineation of Distribution Systems
The Commission may, on request of a mini-grid developer, grant a permit to construct, own, operate and/or maintain an isolated mini-grid in a designated unserved area.
The Commission may, on request of a mini-grid developer, approve a tripartite contract, as agreed with the respective connected community and distribution licensee, to construct, operate and/or maintain an interconnected mini-grid in an under-served area within a geographical location.
A mini-grid developer applying for a mini-grid permit must submit to the Commission an accurate description of the proposed distribution and generation system, including a geographical depiction.
The EPSRA provides the principles and procedures governing the development, operation and maintenance of an effective distribution network. By the provision of Section 62 of the EPSRA, no one may engage in the distribution of electricity unless a distribution licence has been obtained under the Act.
NERC, in its MYTO-2022 Distribution Tariffs, stipulates the tariffs to be charged by DisCos. During these reviews, NERC may vary the DisCos' tariff if there is a material change in the inflation rate and exchange rate.
Pursuant to Section 50 of the EPSRA, any person aggrieved by the decision of NERC with respect to tariffs and prices can apply to NERC for a review of that decision. Moreover, NERC may call for objections or representations in connection with proposed tariffs prior to adoption.
The Market Rules as designed by the market operator also provide for the regulation of the terms of service for participants in the NESI. The Distribution Code would also apply in this instance, as it contains provisions on the role of DisCos.
With respect to independent distribution, the IEDN Regulations provide for certain terms of service.
By the provision of Section 76 of the EPSRA, NERC is empowered to set tariffs and tariff methodologies for the DisCos. Using the MYTO methodology and based on the recommendations of the DisCos, the Commission sets an end-user tariff to cover the costs of electricity (energy and capacity), transmission use of system cost, regulatory and market administration charges, the DisCos’ distribution charges and costs associated with metering, billing, marketing and revenue collection.
NERC aims to provide a viable and robust tariff policy for the NESI, with the aim of ensuring the following:
The MYTO provides a long-term tariff path for the NESI, with minor bi-annual reviews, and major reviews every five years.
The EPSRA in Section 76 (7) requires NERC in preparing tariff methodology to consider any representations made by licence applicants, other licensees, consumers, eligible customers, associations, associations of eligible customers, and such other persons as it considers necessary. NERC is also required to obtain evidence, information or advice from any person who, in the Commission’s opinion, possesses expert knowledge which is relevant in the preparation of the methodology.
Hence, NERC often holds consultations with the relevant stakeholders in the industry before it issues the MYTO or amends the same. The DisCos and the public are often invited to present their submissions on the tariff review, and these are considered in the issuance of the MYTO.
The 2022 MYTO for DisCos, which introduced service-based tariffs and reclassified consumers and tariffs according to the quality and quantity of service to be provided to them by the DisCo, currently applies.
Finally, pursuant to Section 50 of the EPSRA, any person aggrieved by the decision of NERC with respect to tariffs and prices, or any other decision, can apply to NERC for a review of that decision. Moreover, NERC may call for objections or representations in connection with proposed tariffs prior to adoption.
7th Floor
Architects Place
2 Idowu Taylor Street
Victoria Island
70611 Lagos
Nigeria
+234 903 601 9864 / 813 344 7698
info@foundationchambers.com www.foundationchambers.com